High-Quality vs. Bargain Paint: What’s the Real Cost Over Time?

When planning a painting project—residential or commercial—it’s tempting to save money on materials. Paint is paint, right? Not quite.

There’s a clear difference between high-quality and bargain paint—and the true cost only becomes obvious over time. If you’re a homeowner or property manager in Edmonton, here’s what you need to consider before cutting corners on paint.

1. Coverage Efficiency: How Many Coats Do You Really Need?

Cheap paint typically requires 3–4 coats to achieve solid coverage—especially when painting over dark or textured surfaces. High-quality paint often covers in 1–2 coats, thanks to better pigment concentration and formulation.

What that means:

  • Fewer coats = less paint purchased

  • Less labour time = lower application costs

  • Faster project turnaround

Long-term cost: What you “save” on cheap paint often vanishes in added labour and extra gallons.


2. Durability and Wear Over Time

In Edmonton’s climate—cold winters, dry indoor heat, and fluctuating humidity—paint quality matters.

High-quality paint:

  • Holds up better against moisture, heat, UV rays, and everyday wear

  • Resists peeling, cracking, and fading over time

  • Maintains its finish and colour longer

Bargain paint:

  • Fades quickly under sun exposure

  • Chips and peels more easily

  • Often needs repainting within 2–4 years

Bottom line: You’ll repaint more often with bargain paint, increasing long-term costs and disruption.


3. Washability and Maintenance

Walls get dirty—especially in high-traffic areas like kitchens, hallways, offices, and commercial spaces. The paint you choose determines how well your walls clean up.

Premium paint formulas:

  • Are scrub-resistant

  • Don’t lose color or sheen when cleaned

  • Ideal for homes with kids, pets, or businesses with daily traffic

Lower-tier paints:

  • Stain easily

  • Leave visible marks after scrubbing

  • Often require touch-ups or full repaints

Hidden cost: More maintenance, more repainting, and less peace of mind.


4. Adhesion to Surfaces

The quality of adhesion determines whether your paint sticks well to drywall, wood, stucco, or previously painted surfaces.

High-quality paint:

  • Bonds tightly to well-prepped surfaces

  • Reduces chances of blistering or peeling

  • Works better on diverse surface types

Bargain paint:

  • Often lacks the resin content to bond well

  • May peel prematurely—especially in humid areas or bathrooms

In Edmonton homes: fluctuating interior humidity makes strong adhesion essential. Recoating because of flaking paint is a costly redo.


5. Overall Aesthetic Results

There’s an unmistakable visual difference. High-quality paint offers better flow, leveling, and finish uniformity. Whether matte, eggshell, or satin—it looks smoother and more professional.

Professional painters notice (and prefer):

  • Better hide of imperfections

  • Cleaner edges

  • Richer, deeper colours

Bargain paint: may appear uneven, streaky, or dull—especially under natural light.

Impact on value: A professional look increases curb appeal and resale value. Inconsistent finishes can actually hurt perceived property value.


6. Long-Term Financial Comparison

Let’s break it down in a real-world context:

Paint QualityInitial CostLifespanCoats NeededLong-Term Repaint CycleEstimated Cost Over 10 Years
Bargain Paint$$2–4 yrs3–43–4 repaints$$$$$
Premium Paint$$$8–12 yrs1–21–2 repaints$$$

The verdict: The upfront savings from bargain paint are often outweighed by higher labour, more frequent repaints, and a weaker aesthetic result.

Final Thoughts - Paint is a Long-Term Investment

If you’re investing in your home or commercial space, the cost of high-quality paint is minor compared to the long-term return in durability, beauty, and reduced maintenance. The product may cost more per gallon, but it saves you in labour, materials, time, and hassle down the road.

For homeowners and businesses in Edmonton, choosing high-quality paint—paired with expert application—offers the best value by far.

© Leonard's Painting Edmonton, 2024. All Rights Reserved.